Matt Holliday never touched the plate discussion forum

Discussion Forum

Here is the place for serious commentary on the topics at hand. If comments are just made under various posts, discussion of the play will be hampered severely. Post below if you want to be a part of the dialog, or respond to the main posts if you just want your comments to appear there.

Current User: Guest

This forum allows Guest Users to post
Guests may not subscribe to email notifications
Posts by Guest Users will be moderated prior to publishing

Home Forums

Did Matt Holliday Touch the plate?
Weigh in on the topic, post your analysis and comments.

	Topics	Posts
Your initial impressions when you first saw the play and or replay. Post what you remember thinking when you first saw the play and or the replay of Holliday's slide.	1	1
Discussion of the play including Holliday's slide and Barrett's block. THE MAIN TOPIC: Discuss the actual play here.	1	1
Video footage discussion and links Post comments about, and links to, video footage of the slide. Please refrain from rickrolling.	2	2
Pictures of the slide. Please link to photos that depict the slide.	0	0

Tim McClelland discussion area.
This is for all topics centered on home plate umpire Tim McClelland

Forums		Topics	Posts
	McClelland's performance on this play.	0	0
	McClelland's previous history of calls Pine tar, non call on dropped third strikes, etc.	0	0

Argue about the baseball rules involved
Please keep specific discussion about illegal blocking of the plate, obstruction and other topics here.

Forums		Topics	Posts
	Rule 2.0 vs 7.06(b) - Obstruction calls and their application Since McClelland never mentions the topic of obstruction, nor gives the signal for obstruction, this point is moot. But feel free to discuss it.	0	0
	Rules pertaining to umpires A good place to bring up the rule forbidding umpires from making up for a bad call on another call later on.	0	0

What next if Holliday was called out?
While not the subject of this site, some may wish to discuss this.

Forums		Topics	Posts
	Results of the Padres vs. Rockies game. The effect on just the one game tie-breaker.	0	0
	Implications in later playoff games.	0	0

Most Recent Posts

	Started	Last Post	Posts
Your initial impressions when you first saw the play and or replay. Not just Padre fans ...	October 10, 2007-4:14 pm by LynchMob	October 10, 2007 - 4:14 pm by LynchMob	1
Discussion of the play including Holliday's slide and Barrett's block. They all know ...	October 8, 2007-11:58 pm by LynchMob	October 8, 2007 - 11:58 pm by LynchMob	1
Video footage discussion and links ESPN's POST GAME Sportscenter footage	October 8, 2007-3:39 pm by admin	October 8, 2007 - 3:39 pm by admin	1
Video footage discussion and links The ESPN video - the crucial master shot.	October 7, 2007-10:37 pm by admin	October 7, 2007 - 10:37 pm by admin	1

About the Holliday Never Touched the Plate forum
Currently Online: 3 Guests Maximum Online: 5	Forums: Groups: 4 Forums: 10 Topics: 4 Posts: 4	Members: There are -1 members There are 2 guests admin has made 2 posts	Top Posters:

About the Holliday Never Touched the Plate forum

Currently Online:

3 Guests

Maximum Online: 5

Forums:

Groups: 4

Forums: 10

Topics: 4

Posts: 4

Members:

There are -1 members

There are 2 guests

admin has made 2 posts

Top Posters:

Simple Forum - Version 2.0 (Build 207)

Simple Forum WordPress Plugin created by Andy Staines: Yellow Swordfish

Default 'Silk' Icon Set created by Mark James: fam fam fam

Math Spam Protection based on code by Michael Woehrer: Software Guide

Registration Blacklist based on WP-Deadbolt code by whoo: Village Idiot

Tabbed Admin uses Tabifier by Patrick Fitzgerald: BarelyFitz Designs

My thanks to all the people who have aided, abetted, suggested and helped test this plugin

Holliday Never Touched the Plate

Matt Holliday missed the plate in the Padres vs. Rockies 2007 Wild Card one game playoff

Discussion Forum